Proxmox, Docker or a NAS: what do you actually need?

Three popular building blocks with very different jobs. Learn what each one does and which combination suits your goals and budget.

The short answer

Proxmox VE is a hypervisor: it runs several separate virtual computers on one physical machine. Docker runs individual applications in lightweight containers. A NAS, or network-attached storage, keeps your files safe and shares them across your network.

They solve different problems. If you mainly want to store and back up files, start with a NAS. If you want to run a handful of self-hosted applications, Docker on any Linux computer is enough. If you want to experiment with several operating systems or keep services strictly separate, Proxmox is the strongest foundation. New to home labs? Start with our guide to setting up your first home lab.

What is Proxmox VE?

Proxmox Virtual Environment is a free, open-source platform for running virtual machines and lightweight Linux containers. You install it directly on a computer, then manage everything through a web interface.

Proxmox is a good fit when you want to:

  • run several operating systems side by side, such as Linux, Windows and Home Assistant
  • keep services isolated, so a problem in one does not affect the others
  • take snapshots before changes and roll back if something breaks
  • learn the same skills used in business virtualisation

The trade-off is a steeper learning curve and higher memory use, because each virtual machine needs its own share of memory.

What is Docker?

Docker packages an application with everything it needs into a container. Containers share the host operating system, so they start quickly and use far fewer resources than full virtual machines.

Docker is a good fit when you want to:

  • run popular self-hosted applications such as Nextcloud, Pi-hole or Home Assistant
  • install, update and remove applications quickly and consistently
  • describe your whole setup in a Docker Compose file you can back up and rebuild

The main thing to understand is where your data lives. Container data must be stored in volumes or folders outside the container, or it can disappear when the container is updated.

What is a NAS?

A NAS is a device or computer dedicated to storing files. Products such as Synology, or platforms such as TrueNAS and Unraid, manage several drives together, protect against a single drive failing and share files with every device in the home.

A NAS is the right starting point when your priority is family photos, documents and backups. Many NAS platforms can also run some containers or virtual machines, so they can grow with you.

Remember that drive redundancy is not a backup. If files are deleted, encrypted by ransomware or lost in a house fire, redundancy does not help. Our guide to backups you can actually restore explains why.

How they work together

These tools stack neatly:

  1. Proxmox runs on the physical computer.
  2. A virtual machine inside Proxmox runs Docker for your applications.
  3. Another virtual machine runs Home Assistant.
  4. A NAS, either a separate device or a TrueNAS virtual machine, provides storage and receives backups.

You do not need all of this on day one. Many people start with one layer and add the others as their needs grow.

Which should you choose?

Your main goalA sensible starting point
Store and protect family photos and filesA NAS, with an offsite backup
Run a few self-hosted applicationsDocker on a small Linux computer or mini PC
Learn virtualisation or run several systemsProxmox VE on a mini PC with plenty of memory
All of the aboveProxmox as the base, with Docker and NAS functions inside it

Hardware to consider

For Proxmox, memory matters most, so aim for at least 16 GB. For Docker alone, a modest mini PC or even a Raspberry Pi can be enough. For a NAS, think about how many drives you need, how quiet the device must be and whether you want to expand later. In every case, check the power use at idle, because a home lab runs all year.

Common questions

Can I run Docker inside Proxmox?

Yes. The most common approach is to run Docker inside a Linux virtual machine on Proxmox, which keeps it separate from the host and easy to back up.

Is TrueNAS or Unraid better?

They suit different needs. TrueNAS focuses on data integrity using the ZFS file system. Unraid makes it easier to mix drives of different sizes. Both are good choices for a home NAS.

Do I need a separate NAS if I use Proxmox?

Not necessarily, but keeping at least one copy of your important data on a separate device makes recovery much easier if the Proxmox host fails.